Addressing Changes to the Eagle’s Nest Mine Project

We received a total of 115 comments:

• 105 comments through the Registry
• 10 direct emails

Input was also sought directly from Indigenous communities that received notification about the approval of the terms of reference in 2015.

Most comments expressed concern about Bill 5 in general, while some expressed specific concerns about removing the comprehensive environmental assessment requirements for the proposed Eagle’s Nest mine. Concerns were raised about the potential effects of the project, as it is in an ecologically sensitive area.

All comments received on the proposal were considered. No changes were made to section 1 of Schedule 3 of the Bill. The following is a summary of the comments received on the proposal and how we considered them:

Concern that the proposal would present risks to ecosystems, biodiversity, peatlands and climate impacts, especially in the Ring of Fire region. Many suggested the proposal is weakening environmental assessments and environmental oversight.

Response: The Eagle’s Nest project scope has changed significantly over time and the approved terms of reference is no longer aligned with the project as currently proposed. The project will continue to have strong environmental oversight, including requirements to obtain any applicable environmental permissions.

Concern with the lack of consultation with Indigenous communities on the proposed mine, impacts to Aboriginal and Treaty rights and the need for consent before development proceeds.

Response: The proposed mine will continue to be subject to provincial permissions, including any consultation opportunities that come with those processes.. Ontario will continue to meet its duty to consult obligations to Indigenous communities and respect Aboriginal and Treaty rights, as recognized and affirmed by section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982. Ontario is also committed to advancing economic reconciliation with First Nations partners.

Concern over the lack of transparency, rushed timelines, and reduced opportunities for public input on Bill 5.

Response: The proposal notice was open for 30 days until May 17, 2025. Input was also sought directly from Indigenous communities that received notification about the approval of the terms of reference in 2015. Ministry staff met with Indigenous communities upon request, and there were also opportunities to participate in the legislative process for the bill. Ontario is supporting a strong and independent critical minerals sector while maintaining important environmental protections. The mine will continue to be subject to environmental oversight through environmental permissions, including any consultation opportunities that come with those processes.