This notice was originally published on February 28, 2020 for a 31 day comment period ending March 30, 2020. The notice was republished on March 20, 2020 to extend the deadline to submit comments to April 20, 2020.
March 20, 2020
This consultation was open from:
February 28, 2020
to April 20, 2020
Proposed Regulatory Matters Pertaining to Community Benefits Authority Under the Planning Act, the Development Charges Act, and the Building Code Act.
In May 2019, the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing released More Homes, More Choice: Ontario’s Housing Supply Action Plan. In support of the Action Plan, the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing introduced the More Homes, More Choice Act, 2019 (Bill 108) which received Royal Assent on June 6, 2019. Schedule 12 of the Act, once proclaimed, establishes a new authority under the Planning Act for municipalities to charge for community benefits with respect to land to be developed or redeveloped. Community benefits charges are intended to fund municipal infrastructure for community services, such as land for parks, affordable housing and child care facilities, that are needed to support new residents and businesses associated with new development.
On November 6, 2019, amendments to the community benefits charge provisions under the Planning Act were introduced through the Plan to Build Ontario Together Act, 2019. The Bill received Royal Assent on December 10, 2019. The amendments, set out under Schedule 31 of the Act, include new transition provisions for alternative parkland dedication and a mechanism to appeal a municipality’s community benefits charge by- law to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal.
The community benefits charge authority has not been proclaimed and is not in effect at this time.
This is the second regulatory proposal that the government has posted for public feedback on the proposed components of a new community benefits charge authority. The initial regulatory proposal was posted on the Environmental Registry of Ontario on June 21, 2019 (“Proposed new regulation pertaining to the community benefits authority under the Planning Act”, ERO 019-0183).
This proposal outlines additional matters for public input to inform the further development of the community benefits charge authority and regulation under the Planning Act.
Proposal for public comment
This proposal outlines several matters related to the community benefits charge authority under the Planning Act.
The changes made by the More Homes, More Choice Act, 2019 will mean that municipalities will have two primary funding streams to pay for the increased need for services due to new development.
Development charges are a mechanism for municipalities to pay for the capital costs of infrastructure like roads and sewers associated with new development. The government is also seeking feedback in this proposal on changes to the types of services that could be funded through development charges. It is proposed that development charges could also pay for the capital costs of certain community services such as public libraries, parks development (other than acquiring land for parks) and recreational facilities (see Section #2).
The new community benefits charge would complement development charges by giving municipalities the flexibility to fund growth-related capital infrastructure costs of other community services. For example, funds generated through community benefits charges could be used to support community priorities such as acquiring land for parks, supporting affordable housing or building child care facilities which will be needed due to growth.
A municipality could choose to collect development charges to fund the development of new park facilities or enhance existing parks such as playgrounds and splash pads. To acquire the land needed to build new parks, a municipality would have the option of using one of the following tools under the Planning Act:
- A municipality could apply the basic parkland dedication rate in which a maximum of either 5% (for example, for a residential development) or 2% (for a commercial or industrial development) of a proposed development is dedicated as parkland or cash-in-lieu is provided (section 42 “Conveyance of land for park purposes” and section 51.1 “Parkland” under the Planning Act).
- Alternatively, a municipality could establish a community benefits charge by-law to collect funds to acquire land for parks as well as other community services such as affordable housing and child care. If both a developer and municipality agree, a developer could provide land for parks (rather than a payment). The agreed-upon value attributed to the in-kind parkland contribution would be applied toward the community benefits charge payable.
If a municipality has a community benefits charge by-law in place it cannot apply the basic parkland dedication provisions of the Planning Act.
To implement the new community benefits charge authority, the province is seeking feedback on the following regulatory matters under the Planning Act, the Development Charges Act and the Building Code Act:
- Required content of a community benefits charge strategy
- Services eligible to be funded through development charges
- Percentage of land value for determining a maximum community benefits charge
- Timeline to transition to the new community benefits charge regime
- Community benefits charge by-law notice
- Minimum interest rate for community benefits charge refunds where a by-law has been successfully appealed
- Building code applicable law
1. Required content of a community benefits charge strategy
Before passing a community benefits charge by-law, a municipality must prepare a community benefits charge strategy. The strategy must identify the items that a municipality intends to fund through community benefits charges. It must also comply with any requirements that may be prescribed in regulation regarding the mandatory content that a strategy should address. In preparing a community benefits charge strategy, a municipality must consult, but has the flexibility to determine their consultation approach.
To provide greater clarity about the components of a community benefits charge strategy, it is proposed that a municipality would need to include the following content in their strategy:
- The anticipated type, amount and location of development or redevelopment that would be subject to a community benefits charge
- The anticipated increase in the need for a specific community service (for example, the acquisition of land for parks, affordable housing, child care, etc.) resulting from new development or redevelopment
- A parks plan that examines the need for parkland in the municipality
- The amount of parkland per person currently being provided in the municipality, and if this is planned to increase, decrease or stay the same
- The capital costs associated with the increased need for a specific community service resulting from new development or redevelopment
- The excess capacity that exists in those specific services (for example, the extra capacity that exists in a service that is not currently being used)
- Whether the increased provision of those specific services would also serve existing residents (for example, existing residents may also benefit from new child care facilities that are needed as a result of new development or redevelopment)
- Any capital grants, subsidies, or contributions from other levels of government or other sources like donations that are anticipated to be made to support those specific services
2. Services eligible to be funded through development charges
The Development Charges Act provides authority for municipalities to impose development charges to pay for the increased capital costs of specific services that are needed as a result of new growth.
The services that are eligible to be funded through development charges are listed under subsection 2(4) of the Development Charges Act. The list includes a provision for other services that may be prescribed in regulation. The Planning Act stipulates that services funded by development charges may not be funded by community benefits charges.
When proclaimed, the More Homes, More Choices Act, 2019 will make waste diversion and ambulance services fully recoverable through development charges.
The government is proposing to prescribe additional services to be funded under the Development Charges Act, through regulation.
It is proposed that the following services would be identified in regulation under subsection 2(4) of the Development Charges Act:
- Public libraries, including library materials for circulation, reference or information purposes
- Long-term care
- Parks development, such as playgrounds, splash pads, equipment and other park amenities (but not the acquisition of land for parks)
- Public health
- Recreation, such as community recreation centres and arenas
Development charges may be imposed to fully recover the capital costs related to the provision of these proposed services due to new growth. These proposed services would be ineligible to be funded through community benefits charges.
3. Percentage of land value for determining a maximum community benefits charge
The community benefits charge authority established through the More Homes, More Choice Act, 2019, includes a mechanism to determine the maximum community benefits charge payable for any particular development. The community benefits charge payable cannot exceed the amount determined by applying a prescribed percentage to the value of the land under development.
The ministry is seeking feedback on the proposed prescribed percentages through this posting.
The proposed percentages of land value that would be prescribed in regulation under the Planning Act would be structured as follows:
- single-tier municipalities: 15%
- lower-tier municipalities: 10%
- upper-tier municipalities: 5%
In any particular case, the community benefits charge levied by a municipality could not exceed the amount determined by applying the applicable proposed percentage to the value of the land that is subject to development. The land value would be calculated as of the valuation date, which is the day before the date the building permit is issued in respect of the development or redevelopment.
The community benefits charges levied by municipalities would support the growth- related capital costs of acquiring land for parks, and other community benefits required because of development, such as child care facilities, affordable housing, social services, parking and by-law enforcement. There would need to be a connection between the community benefits charge levied and the increased need for community services associated with new development.
Different percentages are being proposed for single, upper and lower-tier municipalities to reflect the varying service delivery requirements of each tier of municipality to service new growth with community amenities. This percentage structure ensures that the combined percentage for upper and lower-tier municipalities would be equal to the percentage for single tier municipalities.
4. Timeline to transition to the new community benefits charge regime
The date by which municipalities must transition to the community benefits charge authority, if they wish to collect funds for community benefits, would be prescribed in regulation under the Development Charges Act, 1997. The prescribed date would be the deadline for establishing a community benefits charge strategy and by-law in order to charge for the capital costs of services funded through community benefits charges.
The community benefits charge by-law would set out the charge payable in any particular instance, any municipal exemptions, and other details.
It is proposed that the specified date for municipalities to transition to the community benefits charges regime would be one year after the date the proposed community benefits charge regulation comes into effect.
This transition period would allow municipalities to prepare community benefits charge strategies and pass by-laws if they choose to implement a community benefits charge regime.
5. Community benefits charge by-law notice
The Plan to Build Ontario Together Act, 2019 amended the Planning Act to establish a mechanism by which a municipality’s community benefits charge by-law could be appealed to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal. A municipality would be required to provide notice to the public when it passes a community benefits charge by-law. To implement the by-law appeal mechanism, requirements associated with how to provide public notice would be prescribed in regulation.
To implement the appeal mechanism, it is proposed that upon passage of a community benefits charge by-law, a municipality would be required to comply with the following notice provisions. These provisions are similar to the notice provisions under the Development Charges Act regarding the passage of a development charges by-law:
- Notice would be required to be given through newspaper or to every land owner in the area covered by the by-law through personal service, fax, mail or email.
- Notice would also be required to be provided by personal service, fax, mail or email to those individuals who specifically request notice, the clerk of the lower or upper-tier municipality (if and as applicable), and the secretary of every school board having jurisdiction in the area covered by the by-law.
- In order to facilitate public awareness of the passage of a community benefits charge by-law, notice would include the following:
- i. A statement that the council of the municipality has passed a community benefits charge by-law.
- ii. A statement setting out when the by-law was passed.
- iii. A statement that any person or public body may appeal the by-law to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal by filing with the clerk of the municipality a notice of appeal setting out the objection to the by-law and the reasons supporting the objection.
- iv. A statement setting out the last day for appealing the by-law.
- v. An explanation of the charges imposed by the by-law.
- vi. A description of the lands to which the by-law applies, a key map showing the lands to which the by-law applies, or an explanation why no description or key map is provided.
- vii. An explanation of where and when persons may examine a copy of the by-law.
The date on which notice would be deemed to have been given would be:
- the newspaper publishing date if the notice is published by a newspaper
- the date the fax is sent, if the notice is faxed
- the date the email is sent, if the notice is emailed
- the date the notice is mailed, if the notice is sent by mail
6. Minimum interest rate for community benefits charge refunds where a by-law has been successfully appealed
The mechanism to appeal a community benefits charge by-law includes a requirement for municipalities to provide full or partial refunds in the event of a successful appeal. The interest rate paid on amounts refunded must not be less than the prescribed minimum interest rate.
It is proposed that the minimum interest rate a municipality would be required to pay on amounts refunded after successful appeals would be the Bank of Canada rate on the date the by-law comes into force. Alternatively, if the municipality’s by-law so provides, the minimum interest rate would be the Bank of Canada rate updated on the first business day of every January, April, July and October.
This proposal aligns with the prescribed minimum interest rate for refunds of development charges after successful appeals under the Development Charges Act.
7. Building Code applicable law
The Building Code is a regulation under the Building Code Act, 1992. The Building Code sets out minimum administrative and technical requirements for the construction, renovation, demolition and change of use of buildings. It also establishes a list of applicable law that must be satisfied in order to receive a building permit. Municipalities enforce the Building Code and are responsible for issuing building permits for the construction, renovation, demolition or change of use of buildings.
It is proposed that the Building Code be amended to add the community benefits charge authority to the list of items under Division A - Article 18.104.22.168 Definition of Applicable Law. This amendment would establish a mechanism for ensuring the payment of community benefits charges prior to the issuance of a building permit.
Your feedback on the implementation of the community benefits charge authority will inform government decisions on the development of a new community benefits charge regulation under the Planning Act and amendments to regulations under the Development Charges Act and Building Code Act.
Submissions may be made online or provided via email to the contact below.
View materials in person
Important notice: Due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, viewing supporting materials in person is not available at this time.
Please reach out to the Contact listed in this notice to see if alternate arrangements can be made.
Connect with us
Sign up for notifications
We will send you email notifications with any updates related to this consultation. You can change your notification preferences anytime by visiting settings in your profile page.Follow this notice