Comment
The sheer amount of freshwater taking in this proposal is quite concerning. As a member of the
Anishinabek Nation, it is our traditional responsibility and vocation to speak up for those that
cannot speak for themselves. That includes the Earth, water, and all those that need water for
life. It is incumbent on the Government of Ontario to consider all aspects of Indigenous rights
including the requirement to consult with First Nations and to consider Indigenous traditional
knowledge. The amount of water proposed to be taken for industrial purposes is alarming. There is
no measure to determine, to my satisfaction, that the water will be returned to its original clean
and natural state. I've also question with the sustainability of such a large water taking. Given
these factors, there is no way to mitigate my concerns. I must clearly state my opposition to the
proposal. Further, as a member of the Anishinabek Nation I must insist on a full and adequate
consultation process with the members of the Beausoliel First Nation, Chippewas of Rama, Chippewas
of Georgina Island, whose traditional territory that the water taking is being proposed. This
consultation process must include members of local traditional societies, Elders and Indigenous
knowledge holders. I also assert that the Government of Ontario lacks a true understanding,
processes and skillsets to adequately consider, analyze and interpret input and considerations
gleaned from Indigenous traditional knowledge. For example: It is a fundamental Indigenous
understanding that water has a spirit which may be impacted in numerous ways by industrial
activity. The balance between the Earth, animal life, plant life and the water is dependent on
spiritual considerations. First Nations have a specific society that is dedicated to protecting
and speaking for the water. The Midewaanikwe, the Anishinaabe women who are called upon to lift
the water in ceremony, and speak for the water and its protection, must be heard prior to decisions
being made. Many of these women are founders of the Mother Earth Water Walk. It takes many years
of dedication, commitment and learning to obtain the skill sets necessary to understand Indigenous
traditional knowledge with respect to water. It is incumbent on the Province to take steps to
understand the worldview of the Anishinabek, and consider robust accommodation measures that take
into account the traditional and spiritual aspects related to these concerns.
[Original Comment ID: 212497]
Submitted May 17, 2019 11:01 AM
Comment on
CRH Canada Group Incorporated - Permit to take water
ERO number
013-2282
Comment ID
29998
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status