This consultation was open from:
December 20, 2023
to February 3, 2024
Decision details
Bill 165, Keeping Energy Costs Down Act, 2024, received Royal Assent on May 16, 2024. Bill 165 amends the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998 (OEBA) to, among other things[1], require the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) to exempt a person (i.e., project proponent) from leave to construct (LTC) requirements under the OEBA if the OEB is satisfied that the circumstances prescribed by regulations have been met. The Bill 165 amendments with respect to exemption from LTC was proclaimed into force on July 1, 2024.
LTC refers to the OEB approval of the construction of certain energy infrastructure, as required by the OEBA in s.90 and s.92. Currently, any project proponent who wishes to construct a hydrocarbon pipeline beyond certain length, diameter, pressure or cost thresholds (currently $2 million)[2] is required to apply to the OEB for LTC.
Where an LTC is required and prior to granting such applications, the OEB, among other things, determines whether the Crown has adequately discharged its Duty-to-Consult (DTC), if triggered. Indigenous communities that have outstanding concerns about the impact of a project, that is subject to an LTC application before the OEB, on their established or credibly asserted Aboriginal or treaty rights (Section 35 Rights or Rights) can seek intervenor status in the proceeding.
With this legislative change to the OEBA related to LTC exemptions, the government proposed regulations[3] that would require the OEB to exempt hydrocarbon pipeline projects projected to cost more than $2 million and not more than $10 million from the requirement to obtain LTC if the OEB is satisfied that the Crown has discharged its DTC, where triggered. This would entail an application to the OEB seeking an exemption and be subject to an OEB decision as to whether the exemption would be granted. The intent for the regulations related to this change is that the current DTC process will continue to apply to these applications.
This approach supports Ontario’s commitments to build homes faster, reduce regulatory burden, provide a reliable and cost-effective energy supply and preserve existing opportunities for Indigenous communities to be consulted and OEB consideration of the Crown’s DTC.
Analysis of Regulatory Impact
The Bill 165 amendments with respect to exemptions from LTC, enable regulations that aim to improve the approval timelines for energy projects, addressing the concerns raised by stakeholders about outdated cost thresholds, regulatory burdens and timelines associated with OEB LTC hearings. The proposed legislative and related regulatory changes would reduce costs and expedite timelines for the construction and expansion of low-cost pipeline projects, helping to build housing and transit faster. For homes and businesses without natural gas access, the regulation will enable quicker connection to customers.
These projects would still need to obtain all relevant permits and approvals to ensure compliance with environmental, technical, and safety requirements from Ontario ministries, authorities, and municipalities and preserve existing Indigenous consultation opportunities.
[1] See posting 019-8307 for other Bill 165 amendments.
[2] Length, diameter and pressure thresholds are set out in s.90 of the OEBA. The cost threshold is prescribed in Ontario Regulation 328/03.
Effects of consultation
Many of the comments received were in support of the proposal to exempt smaller hydrocarbon pipeline projects from the requirements of OEB LTC, while preserving existing opportunities for Indigenous communities to be consulted and OEB consideration of the Crown’s DTC. Many of these comments noted that the current $2 million cost-threshold was set more than 20 years ago and has not been adjusted, although costs have increased.
Supporting comments also noted that an exemption from LTC requirements would speed up projects, reduce regulatory burden, and reduce costs. A few commenters suggested that the cost threshold could be increased to above $10 million. The upper limit of $10 million, which has been consulted on widely with stakeholders and supported by many comments in this consultation and previous consultations[4], provides an increase to the threshold that is much greater than an adjustment for consumer price inflation since 2003.
Some commenters expressed concern that removing the LTC process could limit detailed information available about some projects. Some commenters also questioned what support would be available for Indigenous communities to participate in the new process. Other comments questioned the need for new natural gas pipelines, that hydrocarbon use should be phased out, and that the OEB should promote green energy.
We also heard from Indigenous communities and considered this feedback.
We decided to proceed with the proposal without modification to provide the government with legislative authority to prescribe in regulations the circumstances under which energy projects can be exempt from OEB leave to construct requirements.
[4] See related postings 019-3041 and 019-4029 (links below).
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
Connect with us
Contact
Stephen Motluk
Original proposal
Proposal details
In 2022, the government modernized the Leave-to-Construct (LTC) process for electricity transmission projects. Following this modernization, additional amendments are proposed to the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998 (OEBA) to allow government to prescribe conditions in regulation to fast-track energy infrastructure project (hydrocarbon and electricity lines) through the Ontario Energy Board’s (OEB) LTC process. If passed, government may propose regulations to exempt energy projects costing between $2 million and $10 million from LTC, if duty-to-consult (DTC) is met. Energy projects of this size often support transit projects or connecting residential properties. This approach would support Ontario’s commitments to reduce regulatory burden, provide a reliable and cost-effective energy supply and preserve existing opportunities for Indigenous communities to be consulted and OEB consideration of the Crown’s DTC.
Currently, the OEBA allows the OEB to exempt any electricity transmission and distribution lines or hydrocarbon pipelines, from the requirements in the OEBA to obtain LTC.
This posting seeks to receive feedback on a proposed approach to amend the OEBA to allow the government to prescribe certain additional conditions in regulation for exemption from LTC requirements for energy projects. Such exemptions would seek to support the government-wide efforts to address timelines related to transit project construction and the need for additional housing stock across the province. The proposed amendments to the OEBA would also allow the government to address transition issues, if any, for those LTC applications that are in progress that may be impacted by any conditions for exemption to be set out in regulation.
While the proposed amendment would likely improve timelines for new homes and transit being built through a fast-tracked LTC process, it would have no impacts on the environment. Any exemption from LTC would still require all project proponents to obtain all relevant permits and approvals, and participate in all other related processes to ensure environmental, technical and safety requirements from Ontario ministries, authorities and municipalities are met before proceeding with construction.
If the proposed amendment to the OEBA is passed, the government may consider proposing regulations that would set out requirements exempting energy projects, that are projected to cost between $2 million and $10 million, from LTC. Under this proposal, such exemption would entail an exemption application to the OEB and be subject to an OEB decision as to whether the exemption would be granted.
Indigenous communities have identified through previous consultation concerns with increasing the LTC cost threshold as it could remove existing opportunities for Indigenous consultation. Therefore, the scope of the OEB’s determination of the exemption application would be limited to consideration of whether the Crown’s DTC with Indigenous communities on the energy project, if triggered, has been discharged. Any such proposal for future changes to regulations would be subject to further stakeholder engagement and consultation with Indigenous communities. Such a proposal would not impact projects projected to cost more than $10 million.
Previous proposals to streamline the OEB’s LTC process for electricity infrastructure were posted to the Environmental Registry in July 2021 and November 2022 and proposals to streamline the OEB’s LTC process for hydrocarbon pipelines were posted to the Environmental Registry in January and July 2021. These proposals explored exempting electricity infrastructure projects exclusively funded by commercial and industrial load and generator customers and that are not expected to have a significant impact on other electricity ratepayers, and increasing the existing cost threshold for the requirement to obtain LTC for hydrocarbon pipelines, as prescribed in Ontario Regulation 328/03, from $2 million to $10 million. Several stakeholders noted that the $2 million threshold, which has not been updated in 20 years and is outdated based on current costs for small pipeline projects, especially in congested urban areas, creates undue regulatory burden, higher costs and longer timelines.
In 2023, the government moved forward with some of the consulted upon exemptions to the OEBA.
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
Comment
Commenting is now closed.
This consultation was open from December 20, 2023
to February 3, 2024
Comments received
Through the registry
8By email
11By mail
0