This consultation was open from:
October 21, 2024
to November 20, 2024
Decision summary
The Highway 413 Act, 2024, received Royal Assent on November 25, 2024. The Act allows the proposed Highway 413 project, a provincial priority highway project, to be built in a more efficient and timely manner, while maintaining appropriate environmental protection.
Decision details
On November 25, 2024, the Highway 413 Act received Royal Assent. The content of the Act is the same as was proposed in the original proposal posting. The Highway 413 Act allows for the timely and efficient construction of Highway 413, in a manner that will maintain appropriate environmental protection. The Highway 413 Act sets out the requirements that must be met before Highway 413 can be constructed. This includes a process for the identification and assessment of the environmental impacts of constructing the highway, except for certain early works projects specified in the Highway 413 Act (“Highway 413 early works projects”). The assessment process builds upon the considerable environmental studies, consultation efforts and work that the Ministry of Transportation (MTO) had undertaken in respect of Highway 413 under the Environmental Assessment Act.
In addition, the construction of Highway 413 remains subject to the requirements of other provincial and federal laws. MTO is required to obtain all applicable provincial and federal authorizations before proceeding with the construction of Highway 413, including the Highway 413 early works projects. These authorizations will address various aspects of environmental protection. This, together with the requirements of the Highway 413 Act, provide appropriate environmental protection in respect of the construction of Highway 413.
Effects of consultation
Effects of consultation
Consultation on the proposed Highway 413 Act took place from October 21, 2024, to November 20, 2024. During this time, a proposal notice was posted on the Environmental Registry of Ontario (ERO) for a 30-day public review and comment period. A separate notification letter was also sent to all Indigenous communities identified by MTO as having been consulted during the Environmental Assessment Act process that was being carried out for Highway 413. The letter included a link to the ERO posting, an offer to meet, and an invitation to a webinar held on November 6, 2024, led by the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (MECP) and MTO to discuss the proposed Highway 413 Act.
A total of 166 submissions were received during the 30-day public review and comment period (159 submissions received via the ERO posting and seven received by e-mail).
During the public review and comment period MECP heard from Indigenous communities, government agencies, organizations, and members of the public about the proposed Highway 413 Act. The comments received included the following concerns about potential impacts:
- Indigenous communities will not be able to participate in meaningful consultation with MTO about the construction of the proposed highway and the impacts it may have on their respective rights and interests
- the EAA exemption for Highway 413 will significantly reduce the environmental assessment (EA) requirements that would be required for the project, narrowing the scope of the EA with respect to geographic scale and impacts
- the Minister of Transportation will have the authority under the Highway 413 Act to exclude from publication certain sensitive natural or cultural heritage features, and their locations, which may be used to prevent review and comment by Indigenous communities and others on impacts to sensitive natural or cultural heritage features, including archaeological resources
- the requirements of the Highway 413 Act do not apply to the Highway 413 early works projects and, as such, the potential impacts that may result from these activities will not be considered and these activities may proceed without providing Indigenous communities with opportunities for meaningful consultation
- the proposed highway will cross significant environmental and natural features, including watercourses, forests, wetlands, agricultural lands and portions of the Greenbelt. These areas are home to a significant number of species and habitats, some of which are at risk or endangered
- the proposed route of the highway will cut through thousands of acres of the Greenbelt and immediately adjacent lands, and the headwaters of the Credit and Humber Rivers among other water systems. Under the Greenbelt Plan, these areas should be protected from development
- the Highway 413 Act exempts MTO from the requirements of the Environmental Bill of Rights for posting any applications for provincial permits or approvals to the ERO for public review or comment
- the Highway 413 Act exempts the construction of the highway from all provincial policies under the Planning Act and brings into question whether the decisions made by MTO about the design of the highway will be consistent with the Provincial Policy Statement and conform to other policies and plans
- concern that under the Highway 413 Act, MTO is authorized to obtain necessary permits under the Endangered Species Act, Ontario Heritage Act, and Environmental Protection Act before the final environmental impact assessment report is completed
- concern that the Highway 413 Act allows for changes to the project that are deemed not “significant” without having to complete or make public the assessment of the change. Furthermore, the term “significant” has not been defined in the Highway 413 Act
- whether there is in fact a need for the proposed highway and whether it will provide congestion relief to the current provincial transportation network
MECP, with support from MTO, reviewed and considered the comments received on the proposal. No changes were made to the proposal for the Highway 413 Act in response to the comments received, in part due to the proposed Act already including provisions related to some of the concerns raised, such as a requirement for MTO to:
- develop and implement an Indigenous Consultation Plan
- carry out an assessment process that builds upon the considerable environmental studies, consultation efforts, and work that MTO had undertaken to advance the Project under the EAA
- Prepare an environmental impact assessment report, to provide an opportunity for written comments to be submitted, and for MTO to document what was done in response to any concerns that are raised
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
135 St. Clair Ave W
4th Floor
Toronto,
ON
M4V 1P5
Canada
Connect with us
Contact
Highway 413 consultation
135 St. Clair Ave W
4th Floor
Toronto,
ON
M4V 1P5
Canada
Original proposal
Proposal details
Proposed Project
The proposed Highway 413 will be a 52-kilometre (km) provincial highway extending from Highway 400 in the east (between Kirby Road and King-Vaughan Road) to the Highway 401/407 ETR interchange in the west connecting the regional municipalities of York, Peel, and Halton. This highway is expected to help manage traffic within the Greater Golden Horseshoe, where by 2031, there will be about 1.5 million more trips by cars and trucks each day.
The construction of Highway 413 will include the construction of:
- A new 400-series highway from Highway 400 in the east to the Highway 401/407 ETR interchange, and
- A 4 km extension to Highway 410 and a 3 km extension to Highway 427 to connect them to Highway 413.
Proposed Legislation
The Reducing Gridlock, Saving You Time Act (RGSYTA) is being introduced to the legislature as the Government of Ontario:
- Recognizes the need to build priority highways faster as our province grows in order to get people and goods out of gridlock and save drivers and businesses time and money.
- Recognizes that accidents and lane closures can worsen traffic congestion and impact the quality of life of Ontarians.
- Is speeding up the delivery of broadband projects that will connect people in all parts of Ontario, including rural areas, with reliable internet access.
- Is building Highway 413, recognizing the importance of this highway to millions of drivers from across Ontario.
Through the proposed RGSYTA, we are proposing a statute – the Highway 413 Act – that will:
- Exempt all activities by or on behalf of the Minister of Transportation that are for or related to Highway 413 from the Environmental Assessment Act, and
- Create an accelerated EA process for the construction of Highway 413 and the extensions of Highways 410 and 427. The process will not apply to Highway 413 early works projects.
In the proposed statute, “Highway 413 early works projects” is defined as specified activities by or on behalf of the Minister of Transportation. These are activities that MTO expects to be ready to proceed with earlier than other parts of Highway 413. Highway 413 early works projects are further described in the section below.
Additionally, in the proposed statute, the “Highway 413 Project” is defined as including the following activities carried out by or on behalf of the Minister of Transportation, and do not include what is defined as Highway 413 early works projects:
- The construction of Highway 413,
- The construction of the extensions to Highway 410 and Highway 427 to connect them to Highway 413.
Under the proposed Highway 413 Act, the Minister of Transportation is required to fulfill the following requirements for the Highway 413 Project:
- Prepare a plan for consulting potentially impacted and interested Indigenous communities, circulate the plan to the communities and implement the plan,
- Assess the impacts of the Highway 413 Project on the environment and identify how negative impacts will be mitigated, based on MTO’s preliminary design for the project,
- Prepare and publish a draft Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) which will include a description of local environmental conditions and studies completed (e.g., fish and fish habitat, terrestrial ecosystems, archaeology, air quality, agriculture, noise, socio-economic, drainage and stormwater management), the assessment of impacts of the Highway 413 Project on the environment based on the preliminary design of the project, a description of how impacts will be mitigated and the record of consultation,
- Provide Indigenous communities, government agencies, interested person and the public an opportunity to comment on the draft EIAR, and
- Prepare a final EIAR, considering any comments regarding the draft EIAR and publish the final on the project website.
The requirements of the proposed Highway 413 Act build upon the considerable work, including studies and consultation, that MTO has undertaken to advance the environmental assessment work it has been doing under the Environmental Assessment Act for Highway 413 since the commencement of the EA process for the Project.
Under the proposed statute, a person is prohibited from carrying out the Highway 413 Project except in accordance with the final EIAR, as amended by any final addendum. However, this prohibition does not apply in respect of a “change to the Highway 413 Project” that is not a “significant change”; as these terms are defined in the proposed statute. Information regarding significant changes and the addendum process can be found below.
The proposed Highway 413 Act also includes:
- An addendum process to deal with significant changes to the project (as set out in the final EIAR). That process includes a requirement to assess impacts and identify mitigation, prepare a draft addendum with an opportunity for comment, and prepare a final addendum and publish it. A change to the Highway 413 Project that is not a significant change can proceed without any process under the proposed Act.
- Regulation-making authority including for:
- adding early works
- prescribing the types of changes considered to be significant
- governing assessment and mitigation of impacts of the Highway 413
- A regulation prescribing additional activities for the purpose of the definition of Highway 413 Project and Highway 413 early works projects may only be made before the notice of the draft EIAR is published on the project website.
- A provision providing that, for the purpose of any provincial plan, the Highway 413 Project and Highway 413 early works projects are deemed to be approved under the Environmental Assessment once the final EIAR is published on the project website.
- A provision providing that clause 3(5)(a) and subsection 3(6) of the Planning Act do not apply in respect of the project and early works.
Under the proposed statute, MTO is not prevented from applying for and obtaining permits needed for construction before completing the accelerated EA process. This includes, but is not limited to, permits/authorizations that may be required under the Endangered Species Act, Ontario Heritage Act and Environmental Protection Act. In addition, the proposed legislation provides an exemption from Part II of the Environmental Bill of Rights, 1993 that includes the posting for public comment requirements for provincial permits and approvals that may be required for the project and that would otherwise be required to be posted.
Early Works Projects
As noted above, the proposed statute exempts Highway 413 early works projects from the Environmental Assessment Act. Under the proposed statute, Highway 413 early works projects are not subject to the accelerated EA process described above, which will allow MTO to proceed with Highway 413 early works projects without having to complete any environmental impact assessment if the Act is passed.
In the proposed Highway 413 Act, the Highway 413 early works projects include:
- constructing an embankment for a ramp near the existing ramp at Exit 330 on westbound Highway 401, connecting to westbound Highway 407 in Halton Region,
- constructing a bridge within the Highway 413 route that is within or near Highway 10 in Peel Region,
- constructing a bridge within the Highway 413 route that is within or near Bovaird Drive West in Peel Region,
- any related activities for the embankment or bridges described in a) to c), and,
- constructing fencing for or related to any of the activities described in a) to d) or for or related to Highway 413.
The embankment and bridges projects were selected based on being located in areas that have been previously disturbed and being ones likely to have fewer environmental impacts compared to other areas of the highway.
Timelines
MECP is seeking comment on the proposed statute during a 30-day comment period, ending on November 21, 2024.
If the legislation is passed, it would come into effect on Royal Assent.
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
135 St. Clair Ave W
4th Floor
Toronto,
ON
M4V 1P5
Canada
Comment
Commenting is now closed.
This consultation was open from October 21, 2024
to November 20, 2024
Connect with us
Contact
Highway 413 consultation
135 St. Clair Ave W
4th Floor
Toronto,
ON
M4V 1P5
Canada
Comments received
Through the registry
159By email
7By mail
0