Commentaire
**1. Undemocratic Concentration of Power**
- Bill 5 gives the Premier and Cabinet unprecedented authority to override provincial and municipal laws, bypassing the legislature and public oversight
- The bill allows the government to designate "special economic zones" where almost any law can be suspended for selected individuals or companies, with no meaningful checks or balances.
**2. Threat to Environmental Protections**
- Bill 5 repeals Ontario’s Endangered Species Act and replaces it with a much weaker regime, removing meaningful protections for endangered, threatened, and special concern species
- The new process allows developers to begin work immediately after online registration, eliminating expert review and safeguards for species and habitats
- The bill also terminates environmental assessments for major projects, risking irreversible harm to ecosystems like the Ring of Fire region
**3. Undermines Indigenous Rights and Consultation**
- Bill 5 enables the government to exempt projects from requirements to consult Indigenous communities, violating treaty rights and constitutional obligations
- Indigenous leaders have strongly opposed the bill, stating it threatens their lands, heritage, and sovereignty
**4. Weakens Community Voices and Public Participation**
- The bill streamlines or bypasses archaeological assessments and public input, silencing local communities and experts in decision-making about development and land use
**5. Risk to Clean Water, Air, and Healthy Communities**
- By removing environmental safeguards, Bill 5 puts Ontario’s water, air, and public health at risk, prioritizing short-term economic interests over long-term well-being.
**6. Sets a Dangerous Precedent**
- Allowing Cabinet to exempt any person, company, or region from any law for any reason undermines the rule of law and could be abused for political or private gain
Soumis le 13 mai 2025 8:00 PM
Commentaire sur
Modifications provisoires proposées à la Loi de 2007 sur les espèces en voie de disparition et proposition de Loi de 2025 sur la conservation des espèces
Numéro du REO
025-0380
Identifiant (ID) du commentaire
141760
Commentaire fait au nom
Statut du commentaire