ood morning, I am the Treasurer/Deputy Clerk for a small municipality of under 2,500 people. Although we are small in population, we are large in area and have many roads, bridges, water & sewer systems, and so on.
It appears as though the new Phase 1 requirements will only require 'core infrastructure assets' to be included. If a Municipality has not yet completed their 2016 AMP that required 'all infrastructure assets', will they be able to publish their AMP with just the 'core assets'?
Require a compilation of a complete inventory of all infrastructures the community is currently obligated to maintain, their condition, an estimate of their remaining life and approximate replacement/ maintenance costs.
I believe that the Strategic Asset Management Policy of a Municipality should include the occupational health & safety hazards and risks that relate to asset management.
This proposed legislation will create additional challenges to already overextended municipal capabilities. Additional staffing and financial commitments are significant.
Costs to rhe rate payer, especially in small rural municipalites will be great. Our municipality has a 1 percent rate increase with a spend of only roughly $40,000. We have 312.sq km do roads to maintain. Water and waste water, arenas and public lands.
The Township of Brock would like to voice their major concern in our capacity to meet the ne planning requirements without additional ongoing financial support.
Will the Ministry be standardizing useful lives of the Core Infrastructure Assets or other assets? This will allow for consistency when reporting or comparing results with other municipalities.
Also, could you elaborate on Green Infrastructure assets, it is not clearly defined.
Under the Asset Management Policy the regulation outlines a number of areas to be considered in the AM Policy relating to climate change and GHG Reductions. I think this should be revised or, like in other sections, give different considerations to different sized municipalities.
Asset management is a worthwhile tool but the implementation of a prescribed policy is not acceptable. A requirement for mandatory, ongoing engineering oversight is cost prohibitive and unwelcome in all small communities and even banding together for a shared service is impractical.
The following resolution was passed by Neebing Council on June 21, 2017 (resolution # 2017-06-152):
WHEREAS Posting 013-0551 on the Environmental Bill of Rights, entitled “Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation”, is posted for public comments until July 24, 2017;
As a municipal CAO/Clerk I must strongly object to the timing of the implementation of the regulation. I believe that asset management planning is an important tool and has many benefits for municipal councils, staff and residents.
Finally! it looks like we are beginning to value the economic and environmental benefits that our trees, soils, creeks, rivers and other natural components offer to sustain our basic existence. that is : our Green Infrastructure!
Municipal staff appreciate the need to provide an asset management framework that is consistent across the province, provides for best practices and links to various strategic municipal planning documents.
If you like breathing then we need trees! Trees are an essential part of our life, work and play. I don't need to tell you all the benefits of having trees as I'm sure you are well aware of them all.
View the comments this notice received through the registry. You can either download them all or search and sort below.
Some comments will not be posted online. Learn more about the comment status and our comment and privacy policies.
Download comments
ood morning, I am the…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2138
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
ood morning, I am the Treasurer/Deputy Clerk for a small municipality of under 2,500 people. Although we are small in population, we are large in area and have many roads, bridges, water & sewer systems, and so on.
Read moreRelated actions
It appears as though the new…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2139
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
It appears as though the new Phase 1 requirements will only require 'core infrastructure assets' to be included. If a Municipality has not yet completed their 2016 AMP that required 'all infrastructure assets', will they be able to publish their AMP with just the 'core assets'?
Read moreRelated actions
Require a compilation of a…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2140
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Require a compilation of a complete inventory of all infrastructures the community is currently obligated to maintain, their condition, an estimate of their remaining life and approximate replacement/ maintenance costs.
Read moreRelated actions
Municipalities are already…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2141
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Municipalities are already over burden by the implementation of PSAB 3150 and the current asset managment reporting requirements.
Read moreRelated actions
I believe that the Strategic…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2142
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
I believe that the Strategic Asset Management Policy of a Municipality should include the occupational health & safety hazards and risks that relate to asset management.
Read moreRelated actions
This proposed legislation…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2143
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
This proposed legislation will create additional challenges to already overextended municipal capabilities. Additional staffing and financial commitments are significant.
Read moreRelated actions
Costs to rhe rate payer,…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2144
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Costs to rhe rate payer, especially in small rural municipalites will be great. Our municipality has a 1 percent rate increase with a spend of only roughly $40,000. We have 312.sq km do roads to maintain. Water and waste water, arenas and public lands.
Read moreRelated actions
Therefore Council directs…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2145
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Therefore Council directs staff to respond to the Province by way of the Environmental Registry that the proposed regulation:
Read moreRelated actions
The Township of Brock would…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2146
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
The Township of Brock would like to voice their major concern in our capacity to meet the ne planning requirements without additional ongoing financial support.
Read moreRelated actions
Will the Ministry be…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2147
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Will the Ministry be standardizing useful lives of the Core Infrastructure Assets or other assets? This will allow for consistency when reporting or comparing results with other municipalities.
Also, could you elaborate on Green Infrastructure assets, it is not clearly defined.
Read moreRelated actions
My Initial Comments on the…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2148
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
My Initial Comments on the new Regulation:
1.If licenced engineer to sign off on – need to provide ongoing funding for municipalities too small to have in-house engineers.
Read moreRelated actions
Under the Asset Management…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2149
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Under the Asset Management Policy the regulation outlines a number of areas to be considered in the AM Policy relating to climate change and GHG Reductions. I think this should be revised or, like in other sections, give different considerations to different sized municipalities.
Read moreRelated actions
Asset management is a…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2150
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Asset management is a worthwhile tool but the implementation of a prescribed policy is not acceptable. A requirement for mandatory, ongoing engineering oversight is cost prohibitive and unwelcome in all small communities and even banding together for a shared service is impractical.
Read moreRelated actions
The following resolution was…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2151
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
The following resolution was passed by Neebing Council on June 21, 2017 (resolution # 2017-06-152):
WHEREAS Posting 013-0551 on the Environmental Bill of Rights, entitled “Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation”, is posted for public comments until July 24, 2017;
Read moreRelated actions
As a municipal CAO/Clerk I…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2152
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
As a municipal CAO/Clerk I must strongly object to the timing of the implementation of the regulation. I believe that asset management planning is an important tool and has many benefits for municipal councils, staff and residents.
Read moreRelated actions
Finally! it looks like we…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2153
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Finally! it looks like we are beginning to value the economic and environmental benefits that our trees, soils, creeks, rivers and other natural components offer to sustain our basic existence. that is : our Green Infrastructure!
Read moreRelated actions
Municipal staff appreciate…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2154
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Municipal staff appreciate the need to provide an asset management framework that is consistent across the province, provides for best practices and links to various strategic municipal planning documents.
Read moreRelated actions
Regarding "Current Service…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2155
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Regarding "Current Service Levels"
Read moreRelated actions
If you like breathing then…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2156
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
If you like breathing then we need trees! Trees are an essential part of our life, work and play. I don't need to tell you all the benefits of having trees as I'm sure you are well aware of them all.
Read moreRelated actions
Ministry of Economic…
Comment on
Proposed municipal asset management planning regulation
Comment ID
2157
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Ministry of Economic Development, Employment & Infrastructure
July 6, 2017
Dear Sir/Madam
Read moreRelated actions