This consultation was open from:
March 24, 2022
to April 23, 2022
Decision summary
The Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing has amended the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation (O. Reg 59/05) to add 13 new Urban River Valley areas.
Decision details
The government is taking bold action to address Ontario’s housing crisis by building 1.5 million homes over the next 10 years. As part of this plan, the government proposed changes to the Greenbelt that would support municipal partners to plan for responsible growth and help build housing faster and in a targeted manner, while leading to an overall expansion of the Greenbelt, including the addition of 13 new URV areas from this proposal. See ERO #019-6216 for more information on the changes to the Greenbelt Plan, Greenbelt Area boundary regulation (O. Reg. 59/05) and the Oak Ridges Moraine Conservation Plan (O. Reg. 140/02).
The public consultation took place from March 24, 2022, through April 23, 2022, and sought feedback on the government’s proposal to change the boundary of the Greenbelt Area, through a proposed amendment to O. Reg. 59/05, to add 13 new URV areas to the Greenbelt. The government received feedback from approximately 49 submissions.
Background
Starting in 2021, the province conducted 2 phases of public consultation related to this proposal.
Phase 1 was a 61-day public consultation from February 21, 2021 to April 19, 2021 (ERO #019-3136) that sought feedback on initial areas of focus to grow the Greenbelt, including a study area for the Paris Galt Moraine and adding Urban River Valleys. The Ministry held technical meetings with municipalities and key stakeholders and met with the Greenbelt Council to seek their feedback. Indigenous communities and organizations were engaged through a separate and parallel process.
Phase 2 was a 30-day consultation on the proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Plan schedules and the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation from March 23, 2022 to April 23, 2022 (ERO #019-4485 and ERO #019-4483), seeking feedback to add 13 new Urban River Valley areas.
Current Proposal
- To complement this proposal and to further address the housing crisis, the government also sought feedback through other ERO postings from November 4, 2022 through December 4, 2022, on:
- ERO #019-6216 proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Plan
- ERO #019-6217 proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation O. Reg. 59/05 that would:
- Remove lands from the Greenbelt Area that could be suitable for residential development in the near term
- Add lands in the Paris Galt Moraine to the Greenbelt Area, designated as Protected Countryside with a Natural Heritage System
- Redesignate lands in the Oak Ridges Moraine Conservation Plan Area that could be suitable for residential development in the near term
- ERO #019-6218 the redesignation of land under the Oak Ridges Moraine Conservation Plan (O. Reg. 140/02)
Together, the proposal to add new Paris Galt Moraine lands and this proposal to add 13 URV areas, totalling 9,400 acres will account for an overall expansion to the Greenbelt of approximately 2000 acres.
The strategic removal of lands from the Greenbelt Area was considered in the context of the objectives and policies of the Greenbelt Plan and the requirement in the Greenbelt Act, 2005 that the total amount of land within the Greenbelt Area shall not be reduced.
Description of Ontario Regulation 59/05
O. Reg. 59/05 was made on February 25, 2005 and established the boundary of the Greenbelt Area pursuant to the Greenbelt Act, 2005. O. Reg. 59/05 has been amended by this regulation to add the following areas to the Greenbelt Area:
- Addition of Stoney Creek in Hamilton as a new URV
- Adding Battlefield Creek in Hamilton as a new URV
- Expansion of Wilmot Creek in Clarington
- Expansion of Soper Creek and Bowmanville Creek in Clarington
- Expansion of Harmony Creek URV by adding Darlington Provincial Park, partially located in Oshawa and partially located in Clarington
- Expansion of Oshawa Creek URVs in Oshawa
- Extension of Fourteen Mile Creek URV in Oakville
- Expansion of Don River URV in Toronto by adding:
- Burke Brooke
- Wilket Creek
- Taylor-Massey Creek
- Expansion of Humber River URV in Toronto by adding:
- Humber Creek
- Black Creek
Purpose of regulation amendment
The purpose of the regulation amendment is to expand the Greenbelt Area to enable the policy coverage of the Greenbelt Plan to be extended to these 13 new Urban River Valley areas. Further changes to the Greenbelt Plan and Greenbelt Area boundary regulation (O. Reg. 59/05) have been made to remove or redesignate 15 areas of land under the Greenbelt Plan and Oak Ridges Moraine Conservation Plan (O. Reg. 140/02) and add lands in the Paris Galt Moraine to the Greenbelt Area. See ERO #019-6216 for more details on other changes resulting from this decision.
Schedules 1, 2 and 4 of the Greenbelt Plan have also been amended to include these new URV areas which equal more than 2,400 acres or approximately 1,000 ha of new land added to the Greenbelt. The overall Greenbelt Area will increase from approximately 810,000 ha to approximately 811,000 ha. The new schedules for the Greenbelt Plan came into effect on December 14, 2022.
An amendment to the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation O. Reg. 59/05 has been made to facilitate these changes. Taken together, these amendments allow for the alignment of policy coverage of the Greenbelt Plan with the updated Greenbelt Area boundary. Changes to O. Reg. 59/05 came into effect on December 14, 2022.
Effects of consultation
Members of the public, municipalities, and a range of stakeholders, including from the environmental, development, agricultural and aggregates sectors submitted feedback. Indigenous communities and organizations also provided feedback.
The Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing held consultation and technical meetings with municipalities, conservation authorities, and stakeholders. The Ministry engaged with Indigenous communities and organizations through a separate and parallel process.
Summary of Comments
- Overall, there was strong support for adding and expanding Urban River Valleys into the Greenbelt, especially among certain municipalities, conservation authorities and some agricultural stakeholders, as well as environmental groups and the public.
- Indigenous communities were generally supportive of Greenbelt expansion but expressed concerns around the degree of environmental protection and treaty rights in URV areas.
- Municipalities, such as the Town of Oakville, the City of Hamilton and Halton Region, provided ideas for adding more Urban River Valleys to the Greenbelt in the future, including Joshua Creek (Oakville) and Coldwater Creek (Hamilton). Conservation Ontario, the association that represents Ontario’s 36 Conservation Authorities, also provided ideas including Twenty Mile Creek and Welland River (Niagara Region), Minesing Wetland Complex, Northumberland County watercourses (Ganaraska River in Port Hope and Cobourg Creek in Cobourg), among others.
- The City of Toronto expressed concerns regarding the suitability of the proposed areas and inconsistency with the application of designation criteria.
- Many individuals also made recommendations for adding more Urban River Valleys to the Greenbelt in the future in order to provide broader watershed scale protection, such as the Carruthers Creek headwaters. Individuals also confirmed support for Urban River Valleys connections already in the Greenbelt, such as Duffins Creek, and Twelve Mile Creek.
- The development sector was generally supportive of the proposed URV designations as the URV policies apply to publicly owned land only.
- Agricultural and environmental stakeholders would support a more comprehensive approach to growing the Greenbelt for the purposes of protecting the most valuable land in the GGH. Environmental stakeholders recommend growing the Greenbelt to include all URVs that connect the Greenbelt to the Great Lakes and inland lakes.
- Conservation authorities, environmental stakeholders, multiple individuals and some agricultural stakeholders suggested that URV policies should apply to privately owned land as well as publicly owned lands. The development sector and some agricultural stakeholders are not supportive of applying the URV policies to privately owned lands.
Effect of the Consultation on this Decision
The Ministry appreciates the feedback received on the proposal to grow the Greenbelt by adding 13 new Urban River Valleys areas to the Greenbelt Plan. After reviewing all of the submissions received, some minor changes were made as a result of consultation to the boundary of the Urban River Valley in the area of the Oshawa Harbour to more accurately reflect municipal and conservation authority input.
To view all maps, including the amended maps of the Greenbelt Area boundary, visit Greenbelt Maps.
To view an office consolidated version of the Greenbelt Plan, visit Greenbelt Plan.
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
Connect with us
Contact
greenbeltconsultation@ontario.ca
Original proposal
Proposal details
In Ontario’s 2020 and 2021 budgets, the government committed to protecting the Greenbelt for future generations by expanding its quantity and quality.
To deliver on this commitment, the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing is launching a phase 2 consultation to grow the Greenbelt to seek feedback on proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Plan and Greenbelt Area boundary regulation (O. Reg. 59/05) to add 13 new and expanded Urban River Valley areas.
The maps available for this consultation outline proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Plan Schedules 1, 2 and 4 and proposed amendments to the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation. Proposed maps can be found on Ontario.ca/page/greenbelt-maps.
While this ERO posting relates specifically to the proposed amendment to the Greenbelt Area boundary regulation (O. Reg. 59/05), there are two related ERO postings as part of the phase 2 consultation:
- ERO number 019-4485 seeking feedback on proposed changes to the Greenbelt Plan that could add new 13 new Urban River Valley areas to the Greenbelt.
- ERO number 019-4803 seeking ideas for adding more Urban River Valleys to the Greenbelt.
Description of regulation
O. Reg. 59/05 was made on February 25, 2005 and established the boundary of the Greenbelt Area pursuant to the Greenbelt Act, 2005.
The proposed regulation would add the following areas to the Greenbelt Area as described in O. Reg. 59/05:
- 13 Urban River Valley areas which provide additional connections through urban settings to expand and integrate the Greenbelt and its systems into the broader southern Ontario landscape, including:
- Addition of Stoney Creek in Hamilton as a new URV
- Adding Battlefield Creek in Hamilton as a new URV
- Expansion of Wilmot Creek in Clarington
- Expansion of Soper Creek and Bowmanville Creek in Clarington
- Expansion of Harmony Creek URV by adding Darlington Provincial Park, partially located in Oshawa and partially located in Clarington
- Expansion of Oshawa Creek URVs in Oshawa
- Extension of Fourteen Mile Creek URV in Oakville
- Provincially identified URV expansions including:
- Expansion of Don River URV in Toronto by adding
- Burke Brooke
- Wilket Creek
- Taylor-Massey Creek
- Expansion of Humber River URV in Toronto by adding:
- Humber Creek
- Black Creek
- Expansion of Don River URV in Toronto by adding
The proposed regulation would be an amendment to O. Reg. 59/05. The final decision on the proposal would be made by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
The proposed regulation is about growing the size and quality of the Greenbelt, and the government will not consider the removal of any lands from the Greenbelt Area as described in O. Reg. 59/05.
Purpose of regulation
The purpose of the proposed regulation is to:
- expand the Greenbelt Area to enable the policy coverage of the Greenbelt Plan to be extended to these 13 new Urban River Valley areas to grow the size and quality of the Greenbelt.
Other related information
The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing is also consulting on a proposed amendment to the Greenbelt Plan under the Greenbelt Act, 2005 to add the 13 URV areas to the Greenbelt Plan Schedules. For more information, see ERO Registry Number 019-4485.
The Ministry is also seeking feedback on other potential expansions to the Greenbelt for the future. For more information see ERO Registry Number 019-4483.
Supporting materials
View materials in person
Some supporting materials may not be available online. If this is the case, you can request to view the materials in person.
Get in touch with the office listed below to find out if materials are available.
Comment
Commenting is now closed.
This consultation was open from March 24, 2022
to April 23, 2022
Comments received
Through the registry
23By email
21By mail
0